If the internet stopped for one week, would society keep running? Society keeps running or Society does not keep running?

Bronze-Tiger-8919

Translated by AI. View original

AI’s answerSociety does not keep running

Community prediction

No votes yet

What do you think will happen? Your vote counts toward the results

Prompt

If the internet worldwide stopped for one week, would society keep running?

Answer from Claude Opus 5.5

To start with the conclusion: if the internet stopped for one week, society would not keep running properly. It's about 3 for "keeps running" to 7 for "doesn't keep running." However, things that run on systems separate from the internet, like electricity and water, would be less likely to stop.

If the internet stops, the biggest problem is "the flow of money and goods"

When the internet stops, what you immediately have trouble with is not social media or video streaming. It's money payments and goods delivery.

  • Cashless payments (credit cards, QR code payments, and many forms of electronic money) often can't be used without communication. In Japan, too, the share of people paying cashlessly exceeds 40%
  • Ordering at supermarkets and convenience stores, and delivery management for trucks, also largely run on systems connected to the internet. After a few days, products start disappearing from the shelves

If the internet stops, what stops and what keeps working?

FieldStops / has troubleKeeps working more easily
PaymentsCashless payments, online bankingCash
ShoppingOnline shopping, ordering systemsIn-store stock
CommunicationEmail, social media, calls over the internetLandlines, some mobile calls
WorkRemote work, cloud servicesOn-site work
Infrastructure of daily lifeSome management systemsElectricity, water, and gas mostly run on separate systems
InformationNews sitesTV, radio

Large-scale outages that actually happened

Nothing has ever stopped entirely, but something close has happened. In July 2024, a faulty update to security software caused about 8.5 million Windows PCs worldwide to fail to start, and systems at airports, banks, hospitals, and elsewhere stopped. This shows that even a partial internet outage can have a big impact on society.

Is there a scenario where society keeps running?

The "keeps running" side also has a path to victory.

  • Much of electricity, water, and gas runs on communication and systems separate from the internet, so it won't stop right away
  • TV and radio are delivered by broadcast, so information still gets through
  • There are some people and companies that can go back to old ways like cash, paper slips, and telephones
  • Japan has many disasters and is prepared to some extent for power outages and communication failures

If conditions change, would society keep running?

  • Stops for just 1 day: 7 keeps running to 3 doesn't
  • Stops for 1 week: 3 keeps running to 7 doesn't
  • Stops for 1 month: 1 keeps running to 9 doesn't
  • Only Japan stops and other countries keep running: 4 keeps running to 6 doesn't (international payments and transactions stop)

The point is that the internet is like a blood vessel: "you can live without it, but without it the flow of society stops."

Takes & replies0

No takes yet. Be the first.