If the dinosaurs had not gone extinct, would humans have been born? Born or Not born?
Bronze-Tiger-8919
Translated by AI. View original
AI’s answerNot born
Community prediction
No votes yet
What do you think will happen? Your vote counts toward the results
Prompt
If the dinosaurs had not gone extinct 66 million years ago, would humans have been born?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get straight to the conclusion, if the dinosaurs had not gone extinct, there is a high probability that humans would not have been born. It's about 2 for born to 8 for not born. However, if we mean "intelligent beings like humans," they might have appeared in a different form.
If the dinosaurs had not gone extinct, the biggest issue is "the mammals' place"
About 66 million years ago, a giant meteorite struck near the Yucatán Peninsula in Mexico, and all dinosaurs except birds went extinct.
Actually, mammals had been on Earth since about the same time as the dinosaurs. However, most mammals of the dinosaur era are thought to have been small, about the size of a mouse, living quietly at night. This is because the places of large-bodied animals were occupied by dinosaurs.
When the dinosaurs disappeared, mammals rapidly spread into the vacated places, eventually leading to the primates and then to humans.
Comparison of the case with dinosaurs and the case without them
| Item | Dinosaurs went extinct (actual history) | Dinosaurs survived |
|---|---|---|
| Large land animals | Mammals (ancestors of elephants, horses, whales, etc.) | Still dinosaurs |
| Body size of mammals | Became larger | Most likely remained small |
| Primates | Appeared and spread soon after the extinction | Even if they appeared, they might have remained small animals in the trees |
| Humans | Appeared about several million years ago | Unlikely to have been born |
Is there a scenario in which humans were born?
The "born" side also has a path to victory.
- Even if the dinosaurs survived, climate change might eventually have weakened them, and their places might have passed to mammals
- Mammals might have followed a different evolution in the gaps left by dinosaurs and developed higher intelligence
There is also the idea that even if not "humans," intelligent beings would have appeared. In 1982, an imagined illustration called "Dinosauroid" was published, suggesting that if a large-brained dinosaur, Troodon, had evolved as it was, it might have taken a human-like form, and it became a topic (opinions among scientists are divided).
If the conditions were changed, would humans have been born?
- The meteorite did not strike, and the dinosaurs continued to thrive: born 1 to not born 9
- The meteorite did not strike, and the dinosaurs declined for another reason several million years later: born 3 to not born 7
- Whether "intelligent beings" rather than "humans" were born: born 4 to not born 6
The story is that we might be here now thanks to a single coincidence 66 million years ago.
Takes & replies0
No takes yet. Be the first.