If humans no longer needed to sleep, would they become happy? Become happy or Not become happy?
Bronze-Tiger-8919
Translated by AI. View original
AI’s answerBecome happy
Community prediction
No votes yet
What do you think will happen? Your vote counts toward the results
Prompt
If humans' bodies and brains could recover without sleeping, would people become happy?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get straight to the conclusion, I think that if we no longer needed to sleep, people would become slightly happier. It's about 5.5 for becoming happy to 4.5 for not becoming happy. However, if "work" takes over the extra time, some people will end up unhappier than they are now.
Here, I'll consider this under the premise that "even without sleeping, the body and brain recover just as if you had slept."
If we no longer need to sleep, the biggest point of debate is "who uses the extra time"
The time adults spend sleeping is around 7 hours a day. If we no longer need to sleep, over 2,500 hours a year of free time is created.
- If that time can be used for hobbies, family, study, and rest, life satisfaction goes up
- On the other hand, if companies and society start assuming that "people can work 24 hours a day," there's a risk that it will only lengthen working hours
Historically, it has often been the case that even when technology frees up time, other work increases to fill it.
If we no longer need to sleep, what changes?
| What changes | Good side | Bad side |
|---|---|---|
| Free time | ◎ You can use all 24 hours a day | The "reason to rest" disappears |
| Work | Easier to cover night shifts | You're expected to work 24 hours |
| Economy | Shops and services run all day | There's no quiet time |
| Dreams | - | You lose the enjoyment of dreaming |
| The division of the day | - | You can no longer "sleep it off and forget" |
Are there scenarios where people don't become happy?
The side arguing that people won't become happy also has strong points.
- Sleep is "the division of the day." Even if something unpleasant happens, the effect of being able to change your mood by sleeping and waking up disappears
- For many people, the time of getting into bed itself is a pleasure
- If "not sleeping" becomes the norm, we might end up in a society where people who want to sleep are seen as lazy
If we change the conditions, would people become happy?
- Being able to choose whether to sleep or not: become happy 8 : not become happy 2
- Everyone becomes unable to sleep (no choice): become happy 4 : not become happy 6
- A society with a cap on working hours: become happy 7 : not become happy 3
- A society where working 24 hours is normal: become happy 2 : not become happy 8
Whether you can be happy in a world without sleep comes down to "whether you can use that time for yourself" rather than "having more time."
Takes & replies0
No takes yet. Be the first.