Godzilla vs Ultraman Who would win?
Both originals (1954 Godzilla vs. 1966 Ultraman)
Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited
Translated by AI. View original
AI verdictGodzilla
Community prediction
No votes yet
Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate
Prompt
If the original Godzilla and the original Ultraman fought, who would win?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get straight to the conclusion, if the original Godzilla and the original Ultraman fought for real, Godzilla has a slightly higher chance of winning. It's about Godzilla 6: Ultraman 4. The deciding factor is Ultraman's limitation of "only being able to fight for 3 minutes on Earth."
The biggest point of debate between Godzilla and Ultraman: "Can Ultraman finish off Godzilla in 3 minutes?"
Here we compare Godzilla from the 1954 film "Godzilla" with the original Ultraman from the 1966 TV show "Ultraman." Since Godzilla's size and power vary greatly depending on the work, we'll keep it to the originals against each other.
- Godzilla (1954): 50m tall, 20,000 tons. Breathes a white heat ray containing radioactivity (atomic breath) from its mouth. Withstood tank shelling and electrified steel towers, and reduced Tokyo to scorched ruins.
- Ultraman (1966): 40m tall, 35,000 tons. Flies through the sky and defeats monsters with his deadly "Specium Ray," fired by crossing his arms in a plus shape. However, on Earth he can only fight for 3 minutes before the Color Timer on his chest finishes ringing.
Ultraman has defeated countless monsters with the Specium Ray. However, Godzilla is a monster that no human weapon could kill, and the only thing in the story that could defeat him was a special device that destroyed the oxygen in water (the Oxygen Destroyer).
If Godzilla doesn't fall from a single Specium Ray, Ultraman's time keeps ticking down.
Why Godzilla has the advantage
- Toughness. His body was completely immune to human weapons.
- No time limit. He can keep rampaging for hours. If he survives the 3 minutes, Godzilla wins.
- The atomic breath. He can shoot Ultraman down from a distance.
Ultraman's path to victory is "the first minute"
- Land the Specium Ray first. If he can hit with a full-power ray right at the start of the fight and finish Godzilla off, Ultraman wins.
- He can fly. Godzilla can't fly, so he can attack from the sky.
- Variety of techniques. Besides the Specium Ray, he has the Ultra Slash (a technique that throws a ring of light) and the strength to lift and throw monsters.
- Ultraman weighs more. At 35,000 tons, he's heavier than Godzilla. He won't be outmuscled in a grapple.
How a real fight between Godzilla and Ultraman would play out
- Early phase: Ultraman appears from the sky and grapples with Godzilla. Godzilla fights back with his atomic breath.
- Middle phase: Ultraman fires the Specium Ray. Godzilla falls but gets back up. The Color Timer starts ringing.
- The finish: If Ultraman can finish Godzilla off with the Ultra Slash or a second ray in the remaining time, Ultraman wins. If Godzilla survives the 3 minutes, Godzilla wins. Considering Godzilla's toughness, the latter is more likely, so Godzilla 6: Ultraman 4.
Comparing the strength of Godzilla and Ultraman
| Category | Godzilla (1954) | Ultraman (1966) |
|---|---|---|
| Size | ○ 50m, 20,000 tons | ○ 40m, 35,000 tons |
| Signature move | ◎ Atomic breath | ◎ Specium Ray |
| Toughness | ◎ Immune to human weapons | ○ |
| Time limit | ◎ None | △ 3 minutes on Earth |
| Flight | None | ◎ |
| Variety of techniques | ○ | ◎ |
Godzilla vs. Ultraman: who's stronger under different conditions
- Both originals (this condition): Godzilla 6: Ultraman 4
- Ultraman has no time limit: Godzilla 4: Ultraman 6
- Godzilla from "Shin Godzilla" (118.5m tall, evolving): Godzilla 8: Ultraman 2
- Ultraman's comrades (the Ultra Brothers) join in: Godzilla 3: Ultraman 7
The difference is that Godzilla is the monster king who "won't fall, won't end," while Ultraman is the giant of light who "always settles it in 3 minutes."
›Follow-up questions (1)
- Question:
Which version of Godzilla is the strongest form of Godzilla?
- Answer:
To get straight to the conclusion, opinions on Godzilla's strongest form differ depending on the work. In terms of size, Godzilla from the animated film "Godzilla: Planet of the Monsters" (2017) is the largest, said to be about 300m tall.
Godzilla's size by work
Work Height (approximate) Features "Godzilla" (1954) 50m The original. Immune to human weapons "Shin Godzilla" (2016) 118.5m Keeps evolving, and fires heat rays from its back and tail too "Godzilla: Planet of the Monsters" (2017) About 300m Grew over 20,000 years. The largest in the series Hollywood version (2014–) Over 100m Getting bigger with each work "Godzilla Minus One" (2023) 50.1m About the same size as the original, with a powerful heat ray Candidates for the strongest Godzilla
- The Godzilla that grew with size and time: The Godzilla from "Planet of the Monsters" stood at the top of Earth's ecosystem over 20,000 years, and its size and power are in a class of their own.
- The Godzilla that keeps evolving: The Godzilla from "Shin Godzilla" changed form and grew stronger many times in the story, and couldn't be stopped until it was frozen.
- The power of the heat ray: The heat ray in "Godzilla Minus One" is depicted as powerful enough to blow away a city in a single shot.
In a fight with Ultraman
In the main discussion, we judged the originals against each other as "Godzilla 6: Ultraman 4." With the Godzilla from "Shin Godzilla" it'd be 8:2, and with the Godzilla from "Planet of the Monsters," it's almost impossible for Ultraman to defeat it in 3 minutes.
Godzilla is a monster that has grown by carrying "the fear of its era" with each work.
Takes & replies1
あえてウルトラマン派の立場で言うと、初代ウルトラマンは、3分の中で何十体もの怪獣を倒してきた実績があります。 負けたのは、最終回のゼットンくらいです。ゼットンはスペシウム光線を吸収して跳ね返す、特別な相手でした。ゴジラの放射熱線は強力ですが、スペシウム光線を跳ね返すような力はありません。 スペシウム光線が「効く」相手なら、3分あれば十分、とも考えられます。 ゴジラ派の人に聞きたいです。初代ゴジラは、スペシウム光線を何発まで耐えられると思いますか?