Einstein vs Newton Who is better?

Who is the greatest physicist in history?

Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited

Translated by AI. View original

AI verdictNewton

Community prediction

No votes yet

Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate

Prompt

Einstein vs. Newton: who is the greatest physicist in history?

Answer from Claude Opus 5.5

To get straight to the conclusion, if you ask who the greatest physicist in history is, Einstein or Newton, most people would probably rank Newton slightly higher. It's roughly Einstein 4 : Newton 6. However, in a survey of physicists, Einstein came in first, so the answer changes depending on what yardstick you use.

Einstein vs. Newton: the main point of contention is whether to rank higher the person who built the foundation or the person who rebuilt it

  • Isaac Newton (1643–1727): In his 1687 Principia, he laid out the three laws of motion and the law of universal gravitation. He was the first to show that the motion of objects and the motion of celestial bodies could be explained by the same laws. He devised calculus (alongside Leibniz) and also produced major results in the study of light.
  • Albert Einstein (1879–1955): In 1905 he published special relativity (including E=mc²) and the light quantum hypothesis, in which light behaves as particles, and in 1915 he completed general relativity. The 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded for his explanation of the photoelectric effect.

Newton built the very foundation of the discipline of physics. Einstein rebuilt, with new theories, the areas that Newton's physics could not explain (the world of speeds close to light and of strong gravity).

Reasons to choose Newton

  • He built the foundation from zero. Before Newton, there was no coherent body of physics that explained the motion of objects with mathematical formulas.
  • He also created the mathematics. In order to explain physics, he even created the tool of calculus.
  • It is still used today. Much of the design of bridges and buildings and the calculations for launching rockets are still done with Newtonian mechanics.

Reasons to choose Einstein

  • He changed the way we think about time and space. The idea that the rate at which time passes changes with speed and gravity overturned the common sense of the time.
  • He created two theories almost entirely on his own. Special relativity and general relativity. It is said that it was unlikely that anyone else would have come up with either at the same time.
  • The assessment of physicists. In a 1999 survey of physicists by the British physics magazine Physics World, Einstein was ranked first among the greatest physicists in history, and Newton second.
  • It underpins today's technology. GPS cannot produce a correct position unless the time offset is corrected using relativity.

Comparing the achievements of Einstein and Newton

ItemEinsteinNewton
Main achievementsRelativity, light quantum hypothesisLaws of motion, universal gravitation, calculus
Impact on the discipline◎ Rebuilt physics◎ Created physics
Contribution to mathematics○◎ Calculus
Impact on today's technology◎ GPS, nuclear power◎ Almost all engineering
Survey of physicists (1999)◎ 1st○ 2nd

Einstein vs. Newton: who comes out on top if you change the yardstick

  • Greatest physicist in history (this condition): Einstein 4 : Newton 6
  • If physicists held a popularity vote: Einstein 6 : Newton 4
  • Impact on life today: Einstein 4 : Newton 6
  • The size of the leap of insight achieved alone: Einstein 6 : Newton 4

The difference is this: Newton was the person who "built the foundation of the building called physics," while Einstein was the person who "found the deeper ground beneath that foundation."

›Follow-up questions (1)
  1. Question:

    Between Einstein and Newton, whose IQ is higher?

  2. Answer:

    To get straight to the conclusion, there is no record of either Einstein or Newton ever taking an IQ test. The figures you often see online, such as "Einstein's IQ was 160," have no solid basis.

    Why we can't know the two men's IQs

    • In Newton's time, IQ tests did not exist. The test for measuring intelligence was created around 1905 (by Binet in France). Newton died about 180 years before that.
    • There is no record of Einstein taking one either. IQ tests existed during Einstein's lifetime, but no record remains that he himself took one.

    Where do the IQ figures you often see come from?

    In the first half of the 20th century, there were studies that estimated the IQs of historical geniuses based on records they left as children. Some of the numbers online spread from such estimates or from stories with no clear basis. They are not figures from testing the people themselves, so they are not useful as a way of comparing the two.

    Rather than IQ, the difference between the two geniuses

    • Newton: His mathematical ability was outstanding, and in order to explain physics he even created a new branch of mathematics, calculus.
    • Einstein: From thought experiments in his head, such as "if you chased light at the speed of light, how would light look?", he produced entirely new ways of thinking.

    Newton was a genius who "described the world with mathematics," and Einstein was a genius who "overturned common sense with imagination." They had different kinds of intelligence that cannot be compared with IQ figures.

Takes & replies1