Spartan soldier vs Roman legionary Who would win?
Both with equipment from their peak era. Units of equal size fighting on flat ground
Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited
Translated by AI. View original
AI verdictRoman legionary
Community prediction
No votes yet
Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate
Prompt
If Spartan soldiers and Roman legionaries at their peak fought as units of equal size on flat ground, who would win?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get straight to the conclusion, if Spartan soldiers and Roman legionaries at their peak fought as units of equal size on flat ground, the Roman legionaries have a slightly higher chance of winning. It's roughly Spartan soldier 4 : Roman legionary 6. However, in a one-on-one fight, the answer flips.
The biggest point of contention between Spartans and Roman legionaries: does "individual strength" or "unit flexibility" win?
- Spartan soldiers (around the 5th century BC): They lived in groups from the age of 7 and were raised as warriors (an education called the agoge). Heavy infantry who fight with bronze helmets and armor, a large round shield (aspis), a spear about 2 to 2.5 m long (dory), and a short sword. They push with a dense formation with shields lined up (phalanx).
- Roman legionaries (around the 1st to 2nd century): Soldiers who served long terms as professional soldiers. They fight with armor made of linked iron plates, a large rectangular shield covering the body (scutum), two throwing spears (pilum), and a short thrusting sword (gladius). They can split into small units and flexibly change formation.
In terms of training as an individual warrior, the Spartans, who were raised as warriors from birth, are superior. On the other hand, in terms of freedom of movement as a unit, the Roman legion was superior.
The Roman army has beaten Greek-style dense formations
In the 2nd century BC, the Roman army repeatedly broke Macedonian dense formations (phalanxes) (the Battle of Cynoscephalae, the Battle of Pydna). Even a dense formation that is strong from the front, once the terrain is broken up or gaps appear in the ranks, Roman soldiers split into small units slipped into them and broke them apart.
The Spartan phalanx differs from the Macedonian one in equipment and era, but the pattern of "dense formation vs. flexible unit" is the same.
Reasons the Spartans have the advantage
- Training of each individual. They spent their lives as warriors and had the discipline to hold the ranks without fear.
- Strength in pushing. Pushing in a dense formation with shields lined up is the Spartans' specialty.
- One-on-one strength. In a duel with sword and shield, I consider the Spartans slightly superior.
Reasons the Roman legionaries have the advantage
- Breaking the enemy first with throwing spears. They throw their pila before clashing. When a pilum sticks into a shield it bends and is hard to pull out, so the opponent has no choice but to discard the shield.
- Large shield and short sword. In close pushing, a short sword thrust from behind a large shield is easier to use than a long spear.
- Rotating units. When the front rank tires, they can swap with the rear rank and keep fighting.
How a fight between Spartans and Roman legionaries would unfold
- Early stage: The Romans throw their pila in unison and disrupt the Spartans' shield line.
- Middle stage: The Spartan phalanx advances and pushes in. The Romans receive it with their large shields and look for gaps in the ranks.
- Decisive moment: If the phalanx pushes through without breaking, the Spartans win. If Roman soldiers get into gaps in the ranks, the Romans win. Seeing the Romans, who can rotate their front rank, as slightly favored, it's Romans 6 : Spartans 4.
Comparing the strength of Spartans and Roman legionaries
| Item | Spartan soldier | Roman legionary |
|---|---|---|
| Individual training | ◎ Warrior from birth | ○ Professional soldier |
| Ranged | △ | ◎ Throwing spear (pilum) |
| Pushing | ◎ Phalanx | ○ Large shield |
| Unit flexibility | △ | ◎ |
| Endurance | ○ | ◎ Rank rotation |
| Defense | ◎ Bronze armor and large shield | ◎ Iron armor and large shield |
Who is stronger, Spartans or Roman legionaries, if conditions change
- Units of equal size, flat ground (this condition): Spartans 4 : Romans 6
- One-on-one, with sword and shield: Spartans 6 : Romans 4
- Narrow mountain pass (a place like Thermopylae): Spartans 6 : Romans 4. Their pushing strength comes into play
- Rough terrain, long battle: Spartans 3 : Romans 7
The difference is that Spartan soldiers are "a wall of the strongest individuals lined up," while Roman legionaries are "an organization that keeps fighting while changing shape."
›Follow-up questions (1)
- Question:
Did the Spartans at the Battle of Thermopylae really fight with only 300 men?
- Answer:
To get straight to the conclusion, the Greek army that fought at the Battle of Thermopylae (480 BC) was not just 300 Spartans. Together with soldiers from other Greek cities, it is thought there were initially several thousand.
The real numbers at the Battle of Thermopylae
- Greek army: It is said that together with the 300 Spartans led by the Spartan king Leonidas, plus soldiers from other cities, there were initially about 7,000.
- Persian army: The great army led by King Xerxes. The ancient historian Herodotus wrote that it was over a million, but most modern researchers think it was actually around 100,000 to 300,000.
Those who stayed to the end were not just 300
For two days the Greek army held off the Persian army at the narrow pass. On the third day, when the Persians came through a back route and got behind them, Leonidas sent most of the other soldiers away.
It is said that those who stayed to the end were the 300 Spartans plus about 700 soldiers from Thespiae and about 400 soldiers from Thebes. The story that they "fought with only 300 men" spread as a legend celebrating Spartan courage.
Was the strength of the Spartans real?
Even if the numbers are legend, it is true that they held off a great army for days at a narrow pass. In fighting to defend a narrow place with a dense formation with shields lined up, the Spartans were among the strongest in antiquity.
In the main matchup against the Roman legionaries too, the reason I judged "narrow pass: Spartans 6 : Romans 4" is because of this battle.
Takes & replies1
一対一ならスパルタ、部隊ならローマ。では、スパルタ兵がローマ式の装備と隊形で闘ったらどうなるか、気になります。 スパルタ兵の強さは、生まれたときから戦士として育てられた、一人ひとりの鍛え方です。その兵士が、投げ槍(ピルム)と大盾と短い剣を持ち、小さな部隊に分かれて動けたら、ローマ軍団兵でも勝てないのでは、と思います。 逆に、ローマ軍団兵をスパルタ式の教育で育てたら、という見方もできます。 強さを決めるのは、兵士の鍛え方と、装備と隊形のどちらだと思いますか?