Miyamoto Musashi vs Sasaki Kojiro Who would win?

A rematch at both fighters' peak. Same swords, starting at the same time.

Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited

Translated by AI. View original

AI verdictMiyamoto Musashi

Community prediction

No votes yet

Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate

Prompt

If Miyamoto Musashi and Sasaki Kojiro fought once more, both at their peak and under identical conditions, who would win?

Answer from Claude Opus 5.5

To start with the conclusion: if Miyamoto Musashi and Sasaki Kojiro fought once more, both at their peak and under the same conditions, Miyamoto Musashi is slightly more likely to win. Roughly Miyamoto Musashi 6 : Sasaki Kojiro 4. However, there is a great deal we do not know about the duel at Ganryu Island itself, and "how big the real gap in ability was" is the biggest point of debate in this matchup.

Miyamoto Musashi vs. Sasaki Kojiro: the biggest point of debate is "was the victory at Ganryu Island a matter of skill or of strategy?"

The duel at Ganryu Island is said to have taken place in 1612 (the 17th year of Keicho), on a small island in the Kanmon Strait (Funashima). The well-known story goes as follows.

  • Musashi showed up significantly late for the agreed time, and Kojiro, kept waiting, was irritated.
  • Kojiro used a long sword called the "washing pole."
  • Musashi fought with a wooden sword carved from a boat oar, longer than Kojiro's blade, and won with a single strike.

However, much of this story comes from biographies written more than 100 years after the duel (such as the Nitanki). Whether the lateness really happened, how old Kojiro was (he is said to have been a young swordsman, or alternatively quite advanced in years)—none of this is known for certain.

If it is true that he unsettled his opponent by arriving late and prepared a weapon that outreached his opponent's, then Musashi's victory was a victory not only of swordsmanship but also of strategy. "What would happen if they fought without any strategizing" is the highlight of this rematch.

Reasons Miyamoto Musashi has the advantage

  • Undefeated in his life. In his own Book of Five Rings, Musashi wrote that between the ages of 13 and 29 he fought more than 60 matches and never lost once.
  • Real combat experience. He is said to have had not only dojo matches but also duels with live blades and experience on the battlefields around the time of Sekigahara.
  • Adapting his fighting method to his opponent. Musashi not only devised the two-sword style (Niten Ichi-ryu); his swordsmanship was about changing weapons and distance to suit the opponent and the place.

Sasaki Kojiro's path to victory: the "Swallow Cut" and the "long sword"

  • With a long sword, he strikes first. The "washing pole" is longer than an ordinary sword, allowing him to cut from outside the opponent's reach. At Ganryu Island, Musashi prepared an even longer wooden sword, but with the same swords, Kojiro's would reach first.
  • The Swallow Cut. It is said to be a technique that instantly reverses a downward-cut sword into an upward cut. Even if the first slash is dodged, the second one catches the opponent. However, no detailed record survives of what kind of technique it actually was.
  • Founder of Ganryu. Kojiro was a swordsman who founded a school called "Ganryu," and the island's name, "Ganryu Island," also comes from Kojiro's school.

How a rematch between Miyamoto Musashi and Sasaki Kojiro would unfold

  • Early stage: Kojiro takes the distance of his long sword, and Musashi looks for an opening to step in. Musashi reads the distance by observing the length of his opponent's blade.
  • Middle stage: Kojiro strikes first and follows up with the Swallow Cut. The key moment is whether Musashi can evade this second slash.
  • Decisive moment: If Musashi reads the Swallow Cut and gets inside, Musashi wins. If Kojiro keeps the distance of the long sword, Kojiro wins. Seeing Musashi, with his greater real-combat experience, as slightly favored, it is Musashi 6 : Kojiro 4.

Comparing the strength of Miyamoto Musashi and Sasaki Kojiro

CategoryMiyamoto MusashiSasaki Kojiro
Match record◎ Over 60 matches undefeated (his own account)○ Founder of Ganryu
Distance○ Adapts it to the opponent◎ Long sword
Techniques◎ Two-sword style, fighting method suited to the opponent◎ Swallow Cut
Strategy / psychological warfare◎○
Reliable records○ Has his own book, the Book of Five Rings△ Mainly later biographies

Miyamoto Musashi vs. Sasaki Kojiro: who is stronger under different conditions

  • Both at their peak, same swords, starting at the same time (this condition): Musashi 6 : Kojiro 4
  • Same conditions as Ganryu Island (Musashi has a long wooden sword, arrives late): Musashi 8 : Kojiro 2
  • Kojiro has the "washing pole," Musashi has an ordinary sword: Musashi 5 : Kojiro 5
  • Musashi fights with two swords: Musashi 6 : Kojiro 4

The difference is this: Miyamoto Musashi is a master swordsman who "looks at his opponent and changes how he wins," while Sasaki Kojiro is a master swordsman who "strikes first with a long sword and a reversing technique."

›Follow-up questions (1)
  1. Question:

    Is Miyamoto Musashi's two-sword style really that strong? Did he actually use it in real matches?

  2. Answer:

    To start with the conclusion: Miyamoto Musashi's two-sword style is not a simple technique of "holding a sword in each hand and fighting, so it's strong." Musashi recommended the two swords as a way of thinking aimed at becoming able to handle a sword freely with one hand.

    What Miyamoto Musashi's two-sword style (Niten Ichi-ryu) is

    In the Book of Five Rings, Musashi recommends carrying both a tachi (long sword) and a wakizashi (short sword). The reasons he gives are as follows.

    • On the battlefield, one may hold reins or a spear in one hand. One should be accustomed to handling a sword with one hand.
    • It is not one's intent to die without using the sword at one's hip. Use every weapon one has.

    In other words, the true aim of the two-sword style lay less in "cutting with both hands at the same time" than in "being able to wield a sword at will even with one hand."

    Did Miyamoto Musashi use the two-sword style in real matches?

    Among the recorded matches of Musashi, many were fought with a single sword or a wooden sword. Even at Ganryu Island, it is said that what Musashi used was a single long wooden sword carved from an oar. The two-sword style was probably not "everything" about Musashi's swordsmanship, but one part of his way of thinking: changing the fighting method to suit the weapon and the opponent.

    Is the two-sword style strong?

    AdvantagesDisadvantages
    You can block with one and cut with the otherBecause you swing with one hand, each slash is lighter
    The opponent is unsure which sword to watchFreely using both hands requires long training

    Miyamoto Musashi's two-sword style was not a "technique for overpowering with two swords," but a way of thinking about training—so that one could win with any weapon, even with one hand.

Takes & replies1