Saitama vs Ryomen Sukuna Who would win?
Saitama is serious, Sukuna is at his Heian-era peak (with Domain Expansion)
Bronze-Tiger-8919
Translated by AI. View original
AI verdictSaitama
Community prediction
No votes yet
Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate
Prompt
Who would win if Saitama and Ryomen Sukuna fought? Assume Saitama goes all out, and Sukuna is at his Heian-era peak and can also use Domain Expansion.
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get to the conclusion first, if Saitama and Ryomen Sukuna fought, Saitama would most likely win. It's about Saitama 7 : Sukuna 3.
In the matchup against Gojo Satoru, Gojo's strength was the Infinity—a "wall the fists can't reach." Sukuna doesn't have that wall, so what decides the outcome comes down to a single point: "do Sukuna's slashes get through Saitama's body?"
The biggest point of debate between Saitama and Ryomen Sukuna: "do Sukuna's slashes get through Saitama?"
Sukuna's cursed technique has two types of slashes. There's "Dismantle," which flies at distant opponents, and "Cleave," which adjusts to the opponent's toughness and cursed energy strength so it can cut them down in a single stroke. If he opens his Domain Expansion, "Malevolent Shrine," these slashes will continuously and unfailingly hit everything within the range.
On the other hand, Saitama is a being who is hardly ever depicted taking damage in the series. Even after taking Boros's "Collapsing Star Roaring Cannon," he was unharmed. In the world of One-Punch Man, attacks that have hurt Saitama are almost never depicted.
There's a view that if "Cleave" adjusts to the opponent's toughness, then it should be able to cut Saitama too. On the other hand, Saitama is a being whose upper limit has never been depicted in the series, and he has won without playing along with the logic of his opponents' abilities. Interpretations differ here, but as with the Gojo fight, I judge it in Saitama's favor.
Ryomen Sukuna's path to victory is "Cleave" and guaranteed hits
However, Sukuna has exactly one path to victory.
- Cleave's adjustment: If its property of cutting in accordance with the opponent's toughness works on Saitama too, then he'll be continuously slashed inside the guaranteed-hit domain
- His Heian-era peak body: With four arms and two mouths, he can fight in close quarters while forming hand signs. It's easy for him to create an opening to open his domain
- Reverse Cursed Technique: Even if he takes Saitama's ordinary punches, he may be able to keep fighting while healing. However, whether he can heal from a blow of the "Serious Series" is unknown
Saitama's path to victory: a single blow against an opponent with no wall
- Since Sukuna has no defense like Infinity, Saitama's fists reach him directly
- Saitama has so far defeated almost every opponent with a single blow
- It's natural to see it as Saitama matching Sukuna's speed and getting faster too
How things would unfold if Saitama and Ryomen Sukuna fought
- Early phase: Sukuna unleashes "Dismantle," but Saitama just has his clothes cut and looks unbothered
- Middle phase: Sukuna opens Malevolent Shrine. The guaranteed-hit slashes keep landing on Saitama
- Conclusion: If "Cleave" doesn't get through, Saitama walks up close and finishes it with a serious blow. If it does get through, Sukuna keeps slashing and wins
Comparing the strength of Saitama and Ryomen Sukuna
| Category | Saitama | Ryomen Sukuna |
|---|---|---|
| Weight of a single blow | ◎ Upper limit never depicted | ○ |
| Durability | ◎ Almost never depicted taking damage | ○ Recovers with Reverse Cursed Technique |
| Long-range attacks | △ Wind pressure from his fists | ◎ Dismantle / Open |
| Guaranteed-hit technique | × None | ◎ Malevolent Shrine |
| Defensive wall | — | × No wall like Infinity |
| Decisive factor | A blow that lands | Whether Cleave gets through |
Depending on the conditions, who is stronger can change
- Interpreting it as "Cleave" working on Saitama too: Sukuna 6 : Saitama 4
- Saitama is serious and Sukuna is at his Heian-era peak (these conditions): Saitama 7 : Sukuna 3
- Sukuna can also use the "slash that cuts the world" he learned in the Gojo fight: Saitama 6 : Sukuna 4
The difference is that Saitama is "a hero who's fine no matter what hits him," while Sukuna is "a curse that should be able to cut anything."
Takes & replies0
No takes yet. Be the first.