Madara Uchiha vs Ryomen Sukuna Who would win?

Madara is the Ten-Tails jinchuriki, Sukuna is at his Heian-era peak (with Domain Expansion)

Bronze-Tiger-8919

Translated by AI. View original

AI verdictMadara Uchiha

Community prediction

No votes yet

Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate

Prompt

Who would win if Madara Uchiha and Ryomen Sukuna fought? Assume Madara is the Ten-Tails jinchuriki (Six Paths Madara) and Sukuna is at his Heian-era peak and can also use Domain Expansion.

Answer from Claude Opus 5.5

To get straight to the conclusion, if Madara Uchiha and Ryomen Sukuna fought, the odds are slightly in favor of Madara Uchiha as the Ten-Tails jinchuriki. It's about Madara 6 : Sukuna 4.

Sukuna's Domain Expansion is guaranteed to hit, but Madara, having gained the power of the Six Paths, has a body that won't easily fall even when slashed, and invisible attacks. What decides victory is a single point: "can the guaranteed slashes of Malevolent Shrine finish off Six Paths Madara?"

The biggest point of contention for Madara Uchiha vs Ryomen Sukuna: "can the guaranteed slashes finish off Six Paths Madara?"

Ryomen Sukuna's Domain Expansion "Malevolent Shrine" is a domain that doesn't close with a barrier. Within its range, the slashes of "Cleave" and "Dismantle" endlessly and inevitably hit whatever is inside. Madara has no cursed energy, so he can't use countermeasures like Simple Domain. It's natural to assume the slashes themselves do land.

However, Madara as the Ten-Tails jinchuriki possesses the power of Six Paths senjutsu, and his body's regenerative power is off the charts. In the Fourth Ninja World War, even with Naruto and Sasuke teaming up, he couldn't be finished off easily. There are also scenes depicting that attacks not imbued with the power of the Six Paths won't be a decisive blow.

In other words, this matchup is a contest between "slashes that keep hitting" and "a body that won't fall." How far Sukuna's slashes get through a body possessing the power of the Six Paths isn't depicted in the work.

Madara Uchiha's path to victory is "Limbo: Border Jail" and Truth-Seeking Orbs

  • Limbo: Border Jail: A technique that, with the Rinnegan, sends out another version of himself into an invisible world to attack. Only those who possess the Rinnegan can see it. Whether Sukuna can notice this is a major turning point.
  • Truth-Seeking Orbs: They change shape to become shields or weapons, and have the property of erasing ninjutsu. Whether they also work on Sukuna's cursed technique is open to interpretation.
  • Can fly: He can attack from outside the range of Sukuna's domain with big moves like "Tengai Shinsei," which drops meteorites.

Ryomen Sukuna's path to victory is his domain and a thousand years of experience

Still, Sukuna has exactly one path to victory.

  • Heian-era peak Sukuna has four arms and two mouths, and can fight with other hands while making hand signs
  • It's stated in the work that "Dismantle" is adjusted to cut according to the opponent's hardness and cursed energy strength. If it can adjust to a Six Paths body too, he can keep slashing faster than regeneration
  • With Reverse Cursed Technique, he can fight while healing even after taking Madara's attacks

How a fight between Madara Uchiha and Ryomen Sukuna would go

  1. Early phase: Sukuna gauges the distance with "Dismantle." Madara blocks from the air with Truth-Seeking Orbs and pushes back with Susanoo
  2. Middle phase: Madara's Limbo: Border Jail strikes Sukuna from an invisible direction. Sukuna probes for a response by reading the signs
  3. Conclusion: Sukuna opens Malevolent Shrine. If Madara's regeneration keeps up with the slashes, Madara wins; if it can't, Sukuna wins

Comparing the strength of Madara Uchiha and Ryomen Sukuna

CategoryMadara UchihaRyomen Sukuna
Scale of attack◎ Meteorites, tailed beast power○ Dismantle, Cleave
Regeneration/Recovery◎ Six Paths body◎ Reverse Cursed Technique
Guaranteed-hit technique× None◎ Malevolent Shrine
Invisible attacks◎ Limbo: Border Jail×
Aerial combat◎△
Experience◎◎ Over a thousand years

Depending on the conditions, who's stronger can change

  • Madara in an Edo Tensei body (no Ten-Tails): Sukuna 6 : Madara 4
  • Ten-Tails jinchuriki Madara, Sukuna at his Heian-era peak (these conditions): Madara 6 : Sukuna 4
  • If Madara has time to activate Infinite Tsukuyomi: Madara 8 : Sukuna 2. However, whether he can use it during the fight is open to interpretation

The difference is: Madara is "a Six Paths body that won't fall even when slashed," and Sukuna is "a curse that keeps slashing until you fall."

Takes & replies0

No takes yet. Be the first.