Battleship Yamato vs Battleship Iowa Who would win?

As of 1945, one-on-one gunnery duel

Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited

Translated by AI. View original

AI verdictBattleship Iowa

Community prediction

No votes yet

Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate

Prompt

If the battleship Yamato and the battleship Iowa as of 1945 fought a one-on-one gunnery duel, which one would win?

Answer from Claude Opus 5.5

To get straight to the conclusion, if the battleship Yamato and the battleship Iowa as of 1945 fought a one-on-one gunnery duel, Iowa would have a somewhat higher chance of winning. It's about Battleship Yamato 4 : Battleship Iowa 6. Yamato is superior in main guns and armor, but Iowa is superior in the ability to "find the enemy first and hit first," and that is what decides the outcome.

The biggest point of contention between Yamato and Iowa: "Which comes first, the 46cm guns or radar fire control?"

Both are battleships representing Japan and the United States near the end of World War II. The two ships never actually exchanged fire.

  • Battleship Yamato: A giant ship carrying nine of the world's largest 46cm main guns and displacing over roughly 70,000 tons fully loaded. The side armor is about 410mm thick. Top speed is about 27 knots.
  • Battleship Iowa: Carries nine 40.6cm (16-inch) main guns and displaces about 58,000 tons fully loaded. With a top speed of about 33 knots, it is a very fast ship for a battleship. Its radar-directed fire control was advanced.

The weight of a single shell is about 1.46 tons for Yamato's 46cm shell and about 1.2 tons for Iowa's heavy shell, so Yamato is superior. Yamato's armor is also thicker, so in a straight-up exchange Yamato has the advantage.

The problem is "until it hits." In 1945, American battleships could find the enemy with radar and lay their fire even at night or in bad weather. Yamato also had radar, but it is believed that in fire accuracy the Americans were far ahead.

Why the battleship Yamato has the advantage

  • The world's largest main guns. The 46cm guns are believed to have the power to penetrate Iowa's armor even from far away.
  • Thick armor. It can withstand Iowa's shells for longer.
  • If they exchange fire from far away on a clear daytime sea. Even with optical sights, Yamato's gunnery was excellent, and the difference in main gun power would show directly.

The battleship Iowa's path to victory is "speed and radar"

  • It can choose the fighting distance. Being about 6 knots faster, it can maintain a distance favorable to itself.
  • Find first, hit first. With radar fire control, it can aim even at night or in fog. If it lands the first few hits first, it can destroy Yamato's fire-control equipment or bridge and keep its main guns from showing their power.
  • Rate of fire. Its main guns are said to reload faster than Yamato's, so it has more shells it can fire.

How a shootout between the battleship Yamato and the battleship Iowa would unfold

  • Early stage: At long range, Iowa detects Yamato first with radar and opens fire. Yamato fights back with optical sights.
  • Middle stage: Neither side's shells can easily penetrate the thick parts of the other's armor. Upper structures, fire-control equipment, and turrets break down first.
  • Conclusion: The side that loses its fire-control equipment first can no longer fire effectively and loses. Iowa, which can more easily seize the initiative with radar and speed, is somewhat favored.

Comparing the performance of the battleship Yamato and the battleship Iowa

ItemBattleship YamatoBattleship Iowa
Main guns◎ 46cm guns, 9○ 40.6cm guns, 9
Shell weight◎ about 1.46 tons○ about 1.2 tons
Armor◎ side about 410mm○
Speed○ about 27 knots◎ about 33 knots
Radar and fire control△◎
Size◎ over 70,000 tons fully loaded○ about 58,000 tons fully loaded

The numbers are approximate and vary slightly depending on the source.

Battleship Yamato vs. battleship Iowa: who is stronger if conditions change

  • As of 1945, one-on-one gunnery duel (this condition): Yamato 4 : Iowa 6
  • Clear daytime sea, from close range: Yamato 6 : Iowa 4. The difference in main guns and armor shows
  • Night or bad weather: Yamato 2 : Iowa 8. The radar gap shows directly
  • Like in actual war, with aircraft also used: Neither can beat aircraft with battleships alone. Yamato was sunk by aircraft attack in April 1945

The difference is this: the battleship Yamato is a giant ship that wins on "the weight of a single shell and armor," while the battleship Iowa is a battleship that wins on "speed and the technology to hit first."

›Follow-up questions (1)
  1. Question:

    What is the difference between the battleship Yamato and the battleship Musashi? Which one is stronger?

  2. Answer:

    To get straight to the conclusion, the battleship Yamato and the battleship Musashi are sister ships built to the same design, and their strength is almost the same. The differences lie in small details of equipment and in the course each one took.

    Differences between the battleship Yamato and the battleship Musashi

    ItemBattleship YamatoBattleship Musashi
    CompletedDecember 1941August 1942
    Where builtKure Naval Arsenal (Hiroshima)Mitsubishi Heavy Industries' Nagasaki Shipyard
    Main guns46cm guns, 946cm guns, 9 (same)
    RoleServed as flagship of the Combined FleetLater served as flagship in place of Yamato. Command facilities were reinforced
    FateSunk by aircraft attack on April 7, 1945, while heading for OkinawaSunk by aircraft attack on October 24, 1944, at the Battle of Leyte Gulf (Sibuyan Sea)

    Which is stronger, the battleship Yamato or the battleship Musashi

    Since the main guns and armor are the same design, in a one-on-one shootout it's essentially even. Musashi had reinforced command facilities as a flagship, but that doesn't translate into a difference in fighting power.

    Neither was sunk in a battleship-versus-battleship exchange; both were sunk by aircraft attack. Musashi stayed afloat for hours while taking many torpedoes and bombs, showing the toughness of the Yamato class.

    Why is there no third Yamato-class battleship

    The third Yamato-class ship, Shinano, was converted midway into an aircraft carrier, and construction of the fourth was canceled. This was because the center of the war shifted from battleships to aircraft and carriers.

    The battleship Yamato and the battleship Musashi are sister ships that, while possessing the same power, both marked "the end of the age of battleships."

Takes & replies0

No takes yet. Be the first.