Shohei Ohtani vs Babe Ruth Who is better?
Who is the greatest two-way player of all time?
Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited
Translated by AI. View original
AI verdictShohei Ohtani
Community prediction
No votes yet
Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate
Prompt
Shohei Ohtani vs. Babe Ruth: who is the greatest two-way player of all time?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get straight to the point, if asked whether the greatest two-way player of all time is Shohei Ohtani or Babe Ruth, slightly more people would pick Shohei Ohtani. It's about Shohei Ohtani 6 : Babe Ruth 4. The dividing line in the debate is the difference: for "how long did he keep pitching and hitting at the same time at a high level," it's Ohtani; for "the hitter who changed baseball itself," it's Ruth.
Shohei Ohtani vs. Babe Ruth: the main point of contention is "was he elite at both pitching and hitting in the same season?"
Babe Ruth was the byword for "a true two-way player" until Shohei Ohtani came along. However, the substance of the two men's two-way play is different.
- Babe Ruth: During his Red Sox days he was an elite left-handed pitcher, then with the Yankees he focused solely on hitting and totaled 714 home runs. He excelled at both pitching and hitting mainly in the two seasons of 1918–1919.
- Shohei Ohtani: From 2021 to 2023 with the Angels, he competed for the home run crown every year while pitching as a starter. In 2024 he focused solely on hitting and achieved "50 home runs and 50 stolen bases," and in 2025 he returned as a pitcher.
When compared by how many years he sustained "being elite at both pitching and hitting in the same season," Ohtani comes out ahead.
Comparing the records of Shohei Ohtani and Babe Ruth
Ohtani's numbers are as of November 2026, and since he's still active they will keep growing.
| Category | Shohei Ohtani | Babe Ruth |
|---|---|---|
| Career home runs | ○ 300+ | ◎ 714 |
| Career as a pitcher | ○ 15 wins in 2022, 10 wins in 2023, and in 2026 an 8–2 record with a 1.79 ERA | ◎ 94–46, 2.28 ERA |
| "10 wins and 10 home runs" in the same year | ◎ 15 wins and 34 home runs in 2022 | ○ 13 wins and 11 home runs in 1918 |
| MVP | ◎ 4 times (2021, 2023–2025) | ○ 1 time (the award's rules back then differed from today's) |
| World Series titles | ○ 2 (2024, 2025) | ◎ 7 |
| Stolen bases | ◎ 59 stolen bases in 2024 | △ |
Reasons to pick Babe Ruth
- As a hitter, he changed the era. When he hit 54 home runs in 1920, many other teams had fewer than that as an entire team. The size of his gap over those around him is greater than today's Ohtani.
- He was elite as a pitcher too. His 2.28 ERA is a number good enough that it's said he could have made the Hall of Fame had he focused solely on hitting.
- He kept winning. He won the World Series 7 times.
Reasons to pick Shohei Ohtani
- He's continuing two-way play in today's Major Leagues. Amid a far higher level of player depth and pitcher velocity than in Ruth's era, he is elite at both pitching and hitting.
- In the same year, he was both an ace and a home run title contender. His 15 wins and 34 home runs in 2022 surpass Ruth's 1918, a record unprecedented in modern baseball.
- He can do everything: run, hit, and field. 50 home runs and 50 stolen bases is a kind of greatness Ruth didn't have.
Shohei Ohtani vs. Babe Ruth: who's greater if the conditions change
- Who is the greatest two-way player (this condition): Ohtani 6 : Ruth 4
- Comparing only as hitters: Ohtani 4 : Ruth 6. Ruth's gap over his contemporaries is bigger
- Comparing only as pitchers: Ohtani 5 : Ruth 5. Both were elite in the years they pitched
- If they played in the same era (today's Majors): Ohtani 7 : Ruth 3. The differences in conditioning and training methods are big
Shohei Ohtani is the two-way player who "keeps doing both pitching and hitting in today's baseball for many years," while Babe Ruth is the two-way player who "went from pitcher to hitter and changed baseball itself"—that's the difference.
›Follow-up questions (1)
- Question:
If Shohei Ohtani and Babe Ruth were on the same team, what spots in the batting order would you have them hit?
- Answer:
To get straight to the point, if Shohei Ohtani and Babe Ruth were on the same team, I think the best arrangement is Shohei Ohtani batting first and Babe Ruth batting third.
Why put Shohei Ohtani first
- On-base ability and speed. Ohtani has not just home run power but the speed that recorded 59 stolen bases in 2024. Batting first, he can get on base and create chances with his legs.
- He actually bats first. With the Dodgers, he has appeared in many games as the leadoff hitter. Taking advantage of the extra plate appearances that come with batting first, he can also pile up home runs.
Why put Babe Ruth third
- Ruth was a No. 3 hitter. During the Yankees' heyday, Ruth batted third, with Lou Gehrig batting fourth. This No. 3–No. 4 pair was called the "Murderers' Row."
- His ability to drive in runners. With Ohtani batting first and getting on base, Ruth's extra-base hits come next. It's the lineup that makes it easiest to create scoring patterns.
Other ideas for arranging Shohei Ohtani and Babe Ruth
- Ohtani second, Ruth third: In today's Majors, the idea of putting your best hitter second is also spreading. There's also a form where Ohtani is placed second to get more plate appearances, with Ruth batting third to drive him in.
- What about as pitchers: Both are starting pitchers too, albeit with different handedness. Ohtani (right-handed) and Ruth (left-handed) would give you two pillars in the rotation. On days they pitch, you could also consider moving them down in the batting order to reduce the physical burden.
Shohei Ohtani is the No. 1 hitter who "gets on, runs, and hits," and Babe Ruth is the No. 3 hitter who "drives them in"—that's the arrangement.
Takes & replies0
No takes yet. Be the first.