Genghis Khan vs Alexander the Great Who would win?
Both armies at their peak. Equal numbers, fighting a battle on open plains.
Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited
Translated by AI. View original
AI verdictGenghis Khan
Community prediction
No votes yet
Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate
Prompt
If Genghis Khan and Alexander the Great fought on open plains with equal numbers, who would win?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
In short, if Genghis Khan and Alexander the Great fought on open plains with equal numbers, Genghis Khan would have a slightly higher chance of winning. It's roughly Genghis Khan 6 : Alexander the Great 4. However, Alexander has a "track record of defeating horse archers," and this is the biggest turning point in this debate.
Genghis Khan vs. Alexander: The main point of contention is "can dense infantry catch up to horse archers?"
The two are conquerors who represent world history. Their armies fought in completely different ways.
- Genghis Khan's Mongol army (c. 1162–1227): Almost all were mounted archers. Each man brought several spare horses and could cover long distances in a day. They excelled at raining arrows from afar and at the "feigned retreat," luring pursuing enemies into an encirclement.
- Alexander the Great's Macedonian army (356 BC–323 BC): Dense infantry (the phalanx) wielding 5–6 m long spears (sarissas) held the enemy in front, while cavalry (the Companion cavalry) led by Alexander himself charged from the flank to break them. He never lost a major pitched battle.
On open plains, the Mongol army would seize the initiative in battle thanks to the speed of horses and the range of arrows. The phalanx is good at holding an enemy in front, but it cannot catch an enemy that keeps shooting arrows from afar.
Alexander the Great had defeated horse archers before
Even so, many people say "Alexander would win" because he has a track record.
In 329 BC, Alexander fought and defeated the Scythians, nomadic horse archers, at the Jaxartes River (now the Syr Darya) in Central Asia. He combined light troops and cavalry to lure the Scythians in, pinned down their movement, and then crushed them with cavalry. It is known as a battle in which he observed the horse archers' tactics and devised a countermeasure on the spot.
The Mongol army was a far more organized force than the Scythians. Even so, the fact that Alexander knew "how to fight horse archers" matters a great deal.
Reasons Genghis Khan has the advantage
- The entire army is cavalry. In speed and range of movement, they greatly surpass the Macedonian army. The Mongol army can choose where and when to fight.
- A rain of arrows wears down the phalanx. Dense infantry make easy targets for arrows. Even if they defend with shields and armor, they will break after hours of being shot at.
- Organization and intelligence. An army that operated in units of 10, 100, 1,000, and 10,000, and a method of fighting only after thoroughly scouting the enemy, were far ahead of the rest of the world at the time.
Alexander the Great's path to victory is "forcing a decisive battle"
- Target the Mongol commanders with a Companion cavalry charge. Alexander excelled at charging with cavalry at the spot where the enemy king was and breaking the entire army (the Battle of Gaugamela).
- Choose the terrain. By fighting with a river or hills at their backs, in a place where cavalry cannot go around, the strength of the phalanx comes alive.
- He also has archers and javelin throwers. He can use light troops to shoot back at horse archers and force them to come closer.
How a fight between Genghis Khan and Alexander the Great would unfold
- Early stage: The Mongol army rains arrows from afar, and the Macedonian army endures with shields locked together. Alexander looks for a chance to counterattack with cavalry.
- Middle stage: The Mongol army tries to draw out the Macedonian cavalry with a feigned retreat. The climax is whether Alexander takes the bait.
- Decisive moment: If he is drawn out, the Mongol army surrounds and wins. If Alexander does not take the bait and can drag the Mongol army into close combat, the Macedonian army wins. Judging that the former is more likely on open plains, it's Genghis Khan 6 : Alexander 4.
Comparing the armies of Genghis Khan and Alexander the Great
| Item | Genghis Khan (Mongol army) | Alexander the Great (Macedonian army) |
|---|---|---|
| Mobility | ◎ Entire army is cavalry, with spare horses | ○ Centered on infantry |
| Long range | ◎ Horse archers | ○ Archers and javelin throwers |
| Close combat | ○ | ◎ Phalanx and Companion cavalry |
| Commander's charge | ○ | ◎ The king himself leads from the front |
| Organization and intelligence | ◎ | ○ |
| Fighting horse archers | ◎ Their own way of war | ○ Track record of defeating the Scythians |
Genghis Khan vs. Alexander the Great: who is stronger under different conditions
- Equal numbers, open plains (this condition): Genghis Khan 6 : Alexander 4
- Narrow ground with rivers or hills: Genghis Khan 4 : Alexander 6. Cavalry cannot go around.
- Swapping only the commanders (Alexander leads the Mongol army): Even. Either can draw out the army's strength to the maximum.
- Single combat: Genghis Khan 5 : Alexander 5. Alexander is a king who fought on the front lines himself, and his skill is certain.
The difference is this: Genghis Khan is a conqueror who "dominates the battlefield with speed and arrows," while Alexander the Great is a conqueror who "breaks the enemy with a single decisive blow."
›Follow-up questions (1)
- Question:
If the Mongol army and the Roman army fought, who would be stronger?
- Answer:
In short, if the Mongol army at its peak and the Roman army (the imperial legions of around the 2nd century) fought on open plains, the Mongol army would likely win. It's roughly Mongol army 7 : Roman army 3.
Mongol army vs. Roman army: The main point of contention is "can an infantry legion defeat horse archers?"
- Roman army: Centered on legions of infantry with heavy armor and large shields. Through training, discipline, and the engineering skill to build camps, they dominated the Mediterranean world.
- Mongol army: Almost all were mounted archers. With speed and a rain of arrows, they broke the enemy without letting them get close.
There is a real example of the Roman army being crushingly defeated by horse archers. At the Battle of Carrhae in 53 BC, the Roman army led by Crassus was surrounded by Parthian horse archers and suffered a crushing defeat after being shot at continuously. Even with shields locked together, the enemy did not come close, and when arrows ran out, they resupplied from arrows carried by camels.
The Mongol army was an even larger and more organized force of horse archers than the Parthians.
The Roman army's path to victory is "camps" and "terrain"
- Build camps and defend. The Roman army built camps with earthworks and palisades every night. If they holed up in a camp, cavalry would have a hard time attacking.
- Lure them into land with many mountains, forests, and rivers. In places where cavalry has difficulty moving, the strength of Roman infantry comes alive.
- Add archers and slingers. The real Roman Empire later increased cavalry and archers to counter mounted peoples.
Mongol army vs. Roman army under different conditions
- Pitched battle on open plains: Mongols 7 : Romans 3
- Land with many mountains and forests: Mongols 4 : Romans 6
- Romans holed up in a fortress or camp: Mongols 5 : Romans 5. The Mongol army later also became skilled at siege warfare using Chinese technology.
The difference is this: the Roman army is a force that "endures with discipline and camps," while the Mongol army is a force that "does not let you get close, using speed and arrows."
Takes & replies0
No takes yet. Be the first.