Steve Jobs vs Bill Gates Who is better?
Which one changed the world more?
Bronze-Tiger-8919· edited
Translated by AI. View original
AI verdictBill Gates
Community prediction
No votes yet
Who wins? Your vote counts toward the win rate
Prompt
Steve Jobs vs. Bill Gates: which one changed the world more?
Answer from Claude Opus 5.5
To get straight to the point, if you ask whether Steve Jobs or Bill Gates changed the world more, it's almost a 50/50 split, but most people would probably put Bill Gates slightly ahead. Roughly Steve Jobs 4: Bill Gates 6. The dividing line in the debate is the difference between "how many people it reached" (Gates) and "how it changed the shape of daily life" (Jobs).
Jobs vs. Gates: the main point of contention is whether the person who spread the PC or the person who created new tools changed the world more
- Steve Jobs (1955–2011): He co-founded Apple and brought out the 1984 Macintosh, the 2001 iPod, the 2007 iPhone, and the 2010 iPad. He also nurtured Pixar, which led to the world's first fully CG-animated feature film, Toy Story.
- Bill Gates (born 1955): He co-founded Microsoft and, through MS-DOS, Windows, and Office, spread the same way of using computers to PCs around the world. Later, through the foundation he created with his wife, he has invested enormous sums in things like measures against infectious diseases.
Gates's Windows became the standard for PCs in companies and schools around the world. Meanwhile, Jobs's iPhone defined the shape of the smartphone, a tool that people all over the world now use every day.
Reasons to choose Bill Gates
- The number of people reached. For a long time, Windows was used on the majority of the world's PCs. It standardized the very way work is done around the world.
- He made the PC "one per household." He spread a system in which the same software runs even on cheap PCs, turning computers from something for special people into something for everyone.
- The foundation's work. He spends enormous sums of money on measures against infectious diseases and on health in poor countries. Even outside of business, he has had a huge impact on the world.
Reasons to choose Steve Jobs
- He defined the shape of the smartphone. The iPhone's "touch the screen with your finger to use it" form was carried on by almost every smartphone that followed.
- His philosophy of ease of use. A screen operated with a mouse (the Macintosh), and a screen operated with a finger. He was committed to making tools that "anyone can use without instructions."
- He also changed music and movies. With the iPod and iTunes he changed the way people buy music, and with Pixar he changed the way animated films are made.
Comparing the achievements of Steve Jobs and Bill Gates
| Item | Steve Jobs | Bill Gates |
|---|---|---|
| Signature works | Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, iPad | MS-DOS, Windows, Office |
| Number of people reached | ○ | ◎ |
| Ability to create new forms of tools | ◎ | ○ |
| Impact on the way work is done | ○ | ◎ |
| Impact on daily life and entertainment | ◎ Music, movies, smartphones | ○ |
| Impact outside of business | ○ | ◎ The foundation's work |
Steve Jobs vs. Bill Gates: who's greater if you change the yardstick?
- Which one changed the world more (this condition): Jobs 4: Gates 6
- Who created the tool most used in daily life today: Jobs 6: Gates 4. The smartphone
- As a manager who grew a company: Jobs 5: Gates 5. Both built companies that are among the world's leading firms
- Contribution to society (outside of business): Jobs 3: Gates 7
The difference is that Steve Jobs was the person who "changed the shape of daily life with new tools," while Bill Gates was the person who "spread the PC around the world and changed the shape of work."
›Follow-up questions (1)
- Question:
Were Steve Jobs and Bill Gates on good terms?
- Answer:
To get straight to the point, Steve Jobs and Bill Gates were fierce rivals for a long time, but rather than being enemies, theirs was a relationship of mutual recognition.
How the relationship between Jobs and Gates changed over time
Period Event Early 1980s Microsoft was a partner cooperating with Apple by making software for the Macintosh Mid-1980s onward Microsoft released Windows, and Jobs was furious, saying it was "a copy of the Mac." Apple sued Microsoft, but its main claims were not upheld 1997 Microsoft invested $150 million in Apple, which was struggling financially. Jobs, who had just returned to Apple, made the announcement, and gasps of surprise went up from the audience 2007 The two appeared together in a public conversation and praised each other's work 2011 Before Jobs died, Gates visited Jobs's home and said they talked for a long time Is it true that "Windows is a copy"?
Jobs said Windows was "a copy of the Mac." Gates, on the other hand, is said to have retorted that "both were built by looking at the technology at Xerox's research lab." The idea of a screen operated with a mouse had in fact been created first at Xerox's Palo Alto Research Center.
Having a rival made both of them stronger
Jobs was committed to "tools that are easy to use and beautiful," while Gates was committed to "software that runs on PCs around the world." By competing from different directions, it's fair to say that both PCs and smartphones evolved faster.
Steve Jobs and Bill Gates were rivals who, while fighting, needed each other's existence.
Takes & replies1
あえてジョブズ派の立場で言うと、Windowsの「マウスで操作する画面」は、Macが先に広めたものです。 ただ、そのMacも、ゼロックスの研究所で見た技術をもとに作られました。ジョブズは研究所の技術を製品にし、ゲイツはそれを世界中のパソコンに広めた。どちらも「ゼロから発明した」わけではありません。 そう考えると、世界を変えたのは、最初に作った人より、形にして届けた人なのかもしれません。 新しいものを世界に広めるのに一番大事なのは、発明か、製品にする力か、広める力か、どれだと思いますか?